New Zealand has instructed officials to make its case against possible US restrictions on lamb imports after an American trade investigation moved into a phase where remedies can be considered.
The US International Trade Commission divided three to three on 13 November over whether increased lamb imports were a substantial cause of serious injury to the domestic industry. The split allows the safeguard investigation to continue, but it did not itself impose a new tariff or quota.
New Zealand Trade Minister Todd McClay said on 14 November that he had instructed officials to travel to Washington for a public hearing on possible remedies on 1 December. He argued that New Zealand lamb complements US production and helps meet demand rather than harming American producers.
What the split decision means
The investigation covers lamb meat imported from all sources. It began in July at the request of the US Trade Representative and includes fresh, chilled and frozen products. The legal question is whether imports have increased enough to be a substantial cause of serious injury, or the threat of serious injury, to the domestic industry.
Three commissioners supported an injury finding and three did not. The disagreement concerns imports within the scope of the investigation as a whole; it is not a unanimous finding that New Zealand lamb alone has injured American producers.
The three commissioners who supported an injury finding also made a separate finding that imports from Australia, considered individually, were a substantial cause of serious injury or the threat of it. That country-specific finding was made by the affirmative-voting commissioners, not all six members.
The remedy stage will examine what action, if any, should be recommended. Possible measures in a safeguard case can include higher duties or limits on quantities. The commission will send the views and findings of both groups, along with remedy recommendations, to the US president by 11 January 2027. The president will then decide whether to provide relief and what form it should take.
Opposing views on the market
McClay said New Zealand’s share of US lamb consumption had remained stable for 20 years. His argument is that imports help supply a market in which demand has room to grow, rather than simply displacing American production. New Zealand’s red-meat industry has also argued that imported lamb supports year-round availability for customers.
American sheep producers have put forward a different case. The American Sheep Industry Association says imported lamb has undersold domestic product and contributed to lost sales and market share. It has called for meaningful relief for US producers and welcomed the opportunity to press its case in the next phase.
The association says its economic experts found that imports undersold domestic lamb in more than 90 per cent of price comparisons presented in the investigation. That is the association’s account of the evidence, not a finding agreed by the whole commission. New Zealand’s claim that its exports complement US supply is likewise a position to be considered in the continuing process.
The inquiry is a global safeguard investigation, not an allegation that a particular exporter has dumped goods or received an unlawful subsidy. Such cases examine the impact of increased imports on a domestic industry without requiring proof of an unfair trading practice.
The next stage
The December hearing gives interested parties a further opportunity to address possible remedies. New Zealand’s government says it will continue working with industry and engaging with US counterparts, while its red-meat organisations say they will work with American customers as the case proceeds.
There is no guarantee that a restriction will be introduced. Even if the commission recommends action, the final decision rests with the president. The form, extent and duration of any measure would remain to be determined, and a recommendation should not be confused with a tariff already in force.
The commission says a public report will be available after it sends its findings and recommendations to the president. Until then, exporters and US producers face an unresolved process: the injury vote has opened the way to consider relief, but it has not settled what relief, if any, will follow.