Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin are planning a three-way meeting in China on 19 November, with nuclear weapons among the subjects the US president wants to discuss. A senior US official has cautioned that no agreement on the nuclear issue is expected from the initial conversation.
The proposed talks would take place in Shenzhen on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation leaders’ meeting. US officials announced the plan on 13 November. A spokesperson for the Russian president subsequently confirmed that the three leaders were due to meet in the Chinese city.
It would be the first joint meeting of the current US, Chinese and Russian leaders. The announcement is a plan for talks, not evidence that a summit has taken place or that the three governments have agreed on a nuclear deal.
What the US wants to discuss
US officials say Trump intends to raise the reduction of nuclear weapons. A senior administration official described the encounter as the beginning of a possible longer conversation, rather than a meeting expected to produce an agreement on the subject.
That distinction is important. An opening discussion might establish whether the leaders are willing to pursue further talks, but it would not itself create limits on weapons. Any arrangement would depend on what the parties were prepared to negotiate and how they would agree to verify compliance.
Trump also plans to raise the war involving the US, Israel and Iran, according to the senior US official. The same official said Trump was not expected to raise Russia’s war in Ukraine in the three-way discussion. That describes the US side’s expectation, not a guarantee that the subject cannot arise.
Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, has expressed concern about the possibility of discussions about his country taking place without Kyiv. The US official’s account does not indicate that an agreement on Ukraine is planned at the meeting.
A gap in nuclear arms control
The planned conversation comes after the expiry in February of New START, the last nuclear arms treaty between the United States and Russia. The agreement placed numerical limits on their deployed strategic nuclear forces, including weapons carried by intercontinental missiles, submarine-launched missiles and heavy bombers.
The treaty’s central limits included a ceiling of 1,550 deployed strategic warheads for each country. Its expiration removed those treaty limits; it did not eliminate the weapons themselves. Russia had already suspended the treaty’s verification regime in 2023, before the agreement expired.
Trump has called for an arrangement that includes China as well as the US and Russia. Beijing, however, has argued that its nuclear forces are not on the same scale as those of the other two countries. In October, a Chinese government spokesperson said it was not fair or realistic to ask China to join trilateral nuclear disarmament negotiations at that stage.
That earlier position leaves an important question for any future talks: whether the three countries can agree not only on limits but also on the basis for bringing arsenals of different sizes into the same discussion. The proposed meeting does not settle that question.
The wider summit
The three-way meeting is separate from the formal gathering of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum, or APEC, whose leaders are due to meet in Shenzhen on 18 and 19 November. Xi is scheduled to chair the leaders’ meeting. China’s announcement of his attendance also referred to bilateral meetings with foreign leaders, without naming a three-way encounter.
APEC brings together 21 member economies to work on regional economic cooperation. Its agenda includes trade and investment as well as digital technology and other issues affecting growth. The forum’s commitments are voluntary and decisions are reached by consensus.
Trump and Xi are also expected to hold a separate bilateral meeting during the visit. US officials said they did not expect a separate one-to-one meeting between Trump and Putin. Both the wider gathering and the planned three-way discussion remain ahead of the leaders; their outcomes will depend on the conversations that actually take place.