4°C

overcast clouds

TFL Updates
London Daily News

Why we lie, how to spot it and the science behind the deception

Partner Content
Why we lie, how to spot it and the science behind the deception

By Dr Deborah Lee, Dr Fox Online Pharmacy

One thing The Traitors has shown us for sure, is how to lie – and do it well! Even the faithful lie to bluff and hide the truth.

And lying is very topical just now. We are all only too aware of fake news and social media falsehoods. Moreover, in the true story and bestseller, London Falling, Zac Brettner, a 19-year-old boy, dies from telling the lie that his father is a Russian oligarch. We live surrounded by falsehoods.

  • Why do people lie?
  • How to tell if someone is lying?
  • What can we do about it?

How common is lying?

Although humans are inherently truthful, lying is common and does not necessarily signify a mental health disorder. We often tell white lies so as not to hurt people’s feelings. In general, research shows we lie once or twice a day.

Those who lie are often prolific liars

However, those who tell lies tend to do repeatedly. In another research study 5% of those surveyed produced 50% of all the lies told in the previous 24 hours. Whereas most participants told no lies at all.

Lying without realising it

Sometimes people lie when they don’t realise they are lying. For example, confabulation which is common in dementia or with alcohol abuse disorder (Korsakoff’s syndrome).

It’s important to note that not telling the truth as part of a delusion in a major psychotic disorder such as schizophrenia, is not lying as this is subconscious, the person is living the falsehood, and their belief cannot be shaken. A person with a delusion will say the same thing to anyone as they believe it to be true, whereas a pathological liar can modify what they say depending on who they are talking to.

Pathological lying

Lies can have an underlying medical/psychological cause. People who lie repeatedly over a prolonged period are called pathological liars. Pathological lying is a feature of psychological conditions such as antisocial, narcissistic and borderline personality disorders. In Munchausen Syndrome the person fabricates symptoms and signs to feign illness, which is a form of lying. In ADHD and Bipolar disorder impulsivity can lead to lying as the person has difficulty processing the information and replies without proper consideration.

Psychological reasons for lying

Factors that can increase the risk of lying include

  • Growing up in an abusive household – when a child has to lie to survive.
  • Difficulty with attachment – feeling you need to lie to be loved.
  • Low self-esteem – when you don’t feel important enough to be loved and have to lie to improve your self-image.
  • Extreme anxiety – by fabricating facts you can create a more acceptable world to live in.

Neuroscience of lying

Studies have shown specific areas of the brain are activated when lying – notably the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, the right inferior frontal gyrus and the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. With repeated lying these areas of activation become less pronounced showing the brain becomes habituated to lying. There are also differences in regional connectivity and neural activation in those telling lies and those telling the truth.

Lying is harder work for the brain than telling the truth. When telling lies for personal gain, this can cause an adrenaline rush and a stress response ‘high.’

How to know of someone is lying – 8 signs of deception

  • Focus on speech, not just body language – Listen carefully to phrasing rather than relying solely on non-verbal cues. They are often unemotional – telling the truth evokes emotion.
  • Pronouns are dropped – Liars frequently drop first-person pronouns (“I” or “me”) and shift to third-person language to distance themselves from the statement.
  • Formal phrases – Deceptive speakers often adopt rigid, formal language—such as saying “I did not” instead of “I didn’t.”
  • Unusual speech patterns – Expect long pauses before answering, unusually brief statements, or an overwhelming, unnecessary amount of detail.
  • Qualifying phrases – Frequent use of phrases like “to be honest” or “to tell you the truth” is often a conscious effort to sound credible.
  • Vocal pitch – Pay attention to a voice that sounds strained or shifts to a noticeably higher or lower pitch than normal.
  • Autonomic stress signs – Lying activates the sympathetic nervous system, causing sweating, pupil dilation, facial flushing, or rapid breathing. Note that this can also happen if a person is anxious about a false conviction.
  • Facial and hand gestures – Contrary to popular belief, liars often make prolonged eye contact, raise their eyebrows, or overuse hand gestures to overcompensate.

How to deal with a liar

Living with someone who is lying is stressful and damages relationships. It erodes trust and leads to suspicion, confrontation and arguments.  It can be impossible to get the person to admit they are lying and change their behaviour.

Psychologists recommend

Try not to be confrontational. Instead of ‘You told me X and it’s just not true,’ use open ended phrases such as ‘the story keeps changing. It would help if you could be consistent,’ or, ‘if things change, it would help to have the truth.’

Don’t become a detective, frantically spying and collecting information to prove you are right. This just raises the hostility.

Try setting some boundaries such as ‘next week, let’s revisit this,’ or ‘can we agree to meet same time next week and check on this?’ Stay calm and avoid raising your voice and shouting.

Encourage the other person to get some therapy. There may well be a deep-seated reason for the lying, and the therapist can delve into this and work with them to help them to cope. The therapist can help them learn to control emotions and impulses.

You need to seek support from close friends and family. Your safety is paramount.

If you feel unsafe, reach out –

  • Phone Refuge, the National Domestic Abuse Helpline – 0808 2000 247.
  • This is a free, 24-hour, confidential service
Image by OpenClipart-Vectors from Pixabay

Pin It on Pinterest