Andy Burnham has declined to repeat his chancellor’s support for a third runway at Heathrow, saying he cannot pre-judge the outcome of a government consultation on the airport’s expansion.
John Healey told MPs on 11 November that the government was behind a third runway. Asked about those remarks the following day, the Prime Minister pointed instead to the process for considering consultation responses and taking a final decision.
The exchange highlights different emphases from the two ministers, but it does not by itself establish that the government has changed its policy or that a particular runway scheme has been approved. The planning framework remains under review, and a separate consent process would be required for a detailed project.
Appearing before the Treasury Committee, Healey was asked what assessment his department had made of the economic benefits of a third runway and how quickly they might appear. “The Government are behind a third runway at Heathrow, and I am part of the Government,” he replied.
He said successful airports could act as engines of growth in the surrounding area, citing Manchester and parts of London. Healey added that the Department for Transport, rather than the Treasury, was leading the assessment after the consultation and that the government was working through the responses and additional information.
Speaking to reporters during a visit to Dublin for the European Political Community summit on 12 November, Burnham said: “There’s a consultation that has been taking place.” He added that the government was looking at the replies, that a process was under way and that he could not “pre-judge it”.
Burnham had previously declined to give the project his backing. In September, he said the voices of Londoners should be heard and described the matter as contested. As Greater Manchester mayor, he had opposed expansion partly because of concern that investment in transport in the north would be delayed.
What the consultation covers
The consultation concerned a draft national policy statement: a planning framework against which future applications for expansion would be assessed. It opened in June and closed on 1 September. The government has said it will consider the responses and a parliamentary committee’s findings before deciding whether to proceed with an amended statement.
Any final amended statement would be laid before Parliament and subject to a House of Commons vote before taking legal effect. That would not in itself authorise construction. A developer would still need to submit a detailed application for development consent, which would be examined before a decision by the Transport Secretary.
The government had already supported proposals for a third runway under Burnham’s predecessor, Keir Starmer. In 2025 it selected the north-west runway scheme promoted by Heathrow’s operator to inform the review of the planning framework. That selection did not grant planning permission for the scheme.
Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander has said any expansion must meet tests on economic growth, carbon emissions, air quality and noise. The draft framework also asks promoters to show how extra demand for journeys to and from the airport would be accommodated and how necessary road and rail improvements would be delivered.
Economic case and local concerns
Supporters argue that additional capacity could improve connections for passengers and freight, attract investment and support jobs beyond London. Healey’s comments to MPs placed the airport in that broader argument about growth, while stopping short of providing a new Treasury estimate of the runway’s benefits.
In evidence to MPs in October, the aviation minister said separate departmental analysis estimated cumulative benefits of between £39 billion and £52 billion for passengers and the wider economy. That is an appraisal of possible future benefits, not money that has already been generated. The minister also acknowledged that the economic case was smaller than in the 2018 planning statement.
Others dispute the balance of benefits and impacts. London Mayor Sadiq Khan has opposed the proposals, raising concerns about air pollution, aircraft noise, climate commitments and pressure on transport networks. His office has questioned the evidence used to support expansion and whether the public transport improvements needed to serve it are funded.
The government’s independent climate advisers have said expansion is not compatible with the UK’s net zero target under current policies. They advised ministers to introduce stronger measures requiring the aviation industry to pay for cutting its emissions and removing carbon from the atmosphere. Their assessment is advice to government, not a planning decision.
For communities near Heathrow, the outcome will depend not only on whether ministers support more capacity in principle, but also on the detail of any scheme and the conditions imposed through the planning process. Burnham’s latest answer leaves that decision ahead; it does not announce the construction of a runway.