9°C

scattered clouds

TFL Updates
London Daily News

EU preliminarily finds Temu failed to tackle illegal-product sales

EU preliminarily finds Temu failed to tackle illegal-product sales

The European Commission has preliminarily found that Temu failed to take effective measures to reduce the risk of illegal products being offered on its marketplace. The findings issued on 17 November concern product safety checks, the handling of listings and penalties imposed on sellers.

The case falls under Article 35 of the Digital Services Act, which requires reasonable, proportionate and effective measures to mitigate risks. It is a preliminary assessment, not a final decision that Temu has breached that obligation, and no new fine has been imposed at this stage.

Temu disputes the findings. The company maintains that it invests significantly in compliance systems and human expertise, and that its controls effectively reduce illegal-product risks. It intends to review and respond to the findings while continuing to engage with the Commission.

Safety checks under scrutiny

The preliminary findings challenge whether Temu’s existing controls adequately examine the products themselves against EU safety requirements. The alleged shortcomings go beyond the wording or presentation of an online listing.

One concern is that sellers are required to provide test reports for only a very small share of products. Even when those reports are required, the preliminary case identifies instances in which Temu does not check them.

The findings also question how physical inspections are organised. Temu identifies toys, electronics and cosmetics among its high-risk categories, but allegedly does not give those categories priority when conducting physical checks.

Further concerns include a failure to follow up adequately on the results of spot checks and to increase inspections as the number of listings grows. The announcement does not quantify the proportion of products tested or identify a particular product recall.

Moderation and seller penalties

A second part of the case concerns content moderation. The alleged weakness is that the system appears to concentrate mainly on information attached to listings and compliance with Temu’s own terms and conditions, rather than the safety of the goods being sold.

The preliminary findings also challenge a tool used to compare listings with others previously identified as non-compliant. That system allegedly gives insufficient attention to the risk of unsafe products. Human moderation capacity is another issue: the number of moderators has not grown in line with the increase in listings, under the assessment being put to Temu.

The third area is the way sanctions operate. The preliminary case identifies a fragmented system in which penalties are applied to individual stores rather than the trader behind them. A single trader may operate several stores, so closing one can leave that trader able to continue selling through others.

The findings further allege that traders can commit numerous serious infringements, including selling products that fail safety checks, before any of their stores is suspended. The published assessment does not give a numerical threshold for those infringements.

A separate issue from the earlier fine

The latest development is distinct from the Commission’s earlier decision on Temu’s risk assessment. In May, the company was fined €200 million for failing to conduct an appropriate assessment. An action plan to remedy that breach was approved in October 2026.

The new preliminary finding instead concerns the concrete measures used to mitigate risks. Approval of the earlier action plan therefore does not settle the separate questions now being raised about product checks, moderation and sanctions.

Formal proceedings began in October 2024. Their scope included the sale of illegal products, potentially addictive service design, purchase-recommendation systems and access to data for researchers. The present announcement addresses the risk-mitigation obligation rather than deciding every part of that wider investigation.

Temu can challenge the assessment

Temu can examine documents in the investigation file and reply in writing before the Commission reaches a final position. The European Board for Digital Services will also be consulted.

If the findings are ultimately confirmed, the Commission may adopt a non-compliance decision and require measures to address the breach. A proportionate fine could reach up to 6 per cent of the provider’s total worldwide annual turnover. That is a possible maximum, not an announced penalty or a prediction of the outcome.

No timetable for a final decision or deadline for Temu’s written reply has been set out in the announcement. The next stage leaves the company able to challenge the evidence and conclusions before any new breach is confirmed.

Pin It on Pinterest