7°C

broken clouds

TFL Updates
London Daily News

Victorian election pitches pair public surgery pledge with youth boot camp

Victorian election pitches pair public surgery pledge with youth boot camp

Victoria’s two largest political groupings have set out competing election pitches on hospital waiting lists and youth justice, with Labor promising more public surgery and the Liberal-Nationals Coalition proposing a boot camp for young offenders.

Premier Ben Carroll and opposition leader Jess Wilson launched their campaigns at separate events in Melbourne on Sunday 15 November, ahead of the Australian state’s election on 28 November. Both proposals are election commitments: neither is an operating programme simply because it has been announced.

More operations in public hospitals

Labor says it would spend A$1.17 billion on 100,000 additional planned operations in public hospitals if returned to government. It aims to halve the waiting list for planned surgery and has also pledged more than A$195 million for 500,000 additional specialist appointments.

The party says it would provide more theatre sessions, including in the evenings and at weekends, using additional surgical teams. It has promised that 30 per cent of the extra operations would take place in regional Victoria.

The specialist commitment addresses a different stage of treatment. Patients may need to see a specialist before a decision is made about surgery, so reducing the time spent on an operation waiting list is not necessarily the same thing as reducing the entire wait from referral to treatment. The targets are promises about what Labor intends to achieve, not evidence that the waiting list has already been cut.

The Coalition has previously proposed its own way to halve the surgery waiting list. Its A$1.27 billion plan would pay private hospitals to perform additional operations for public patients, with four-year contracts and a target of 25,000 extra procedures a year. Labor’s new commitment places the additional operations in public hospitals instead. Both plans depend on the party proposing them winning office and carrying out its pledge.

A proposed boot camp for teenagers

At the Liberal launch, Wilson announced a plan to use the former Dhurringile Prison near Murchison in northern Victoria as a boot camp for male offenders aged 14 to 17. Courts would be able to order eligible young people into the programme as an alternative to a community corrections order or a custodial sentence.

The proposed routine would include physical activity, farm work and other tasks such as cleaning and cooking, alongside education. Wilson has said the aim is to give young people discipline and practical skills. The Coalition has put the cost at A$60 million and described an initial two-year pilot to assess the approach. The former prison would need to be made suitable for the proposed use, and no opening date has been set.

The proposal has also raised questions about its treatment of children. Nerita Waight, chief executive of an Aboriginal legal service in Victoria, criticised the plan and asked whether those taking part would be paid for their work or gain qualifications. She argued that therapeutic support and opportunities for young people matter alongside any skills they develop.

The Coalition’s boot camp is distinct from an earlier Labor youth-justice pledge. Labor has proposed an A$204 million scheme of mandatory therapeutic orders under which some young offenders could be placed in secure facilities for up to 12 months. Its proposed programme includes education, mental-health support, drug and alcohol treatment and practical life skills. That, too, is a proposed election measure rather than the same programme as the Coalition’s camp.

The vote ahead

Early voting is due to run from 18 to 27 November, before election day on Saturday 28 November. Voters will choose representatives for both houses of Victoria’s parliament, while the party or coalition with majority support in the lower house forms the state government.

The campaign announcements offer different choices about where additional surgery would take place and how young offenders should be dealt with. Their promised outcomes, costs and delivery would still need to be tested against decisions made after the election.

Pin It on Pinterest