7°C

broken clouds

TFL Updates
London Daily News

EU factory carbon allowance cuts face slower path under Irish plan

EU factory carbon allowance cuts face slower path under Irish plan

Factories across the European Union could see a more gradual reduction in their free carbon allowances under a compromise proposed by the Irish presidency of the bloc’s Council. The draft would also spare some smaller installations from a proposed requirement to submit investment plans for cutting emissions.

The proposal is part of a wider review of the EU Emissions Trading System, the carbon market that places a cost on pollution from power generation, industry and parts of aviation and shipping. It is not an agreed law or even a final joint position of EU governments.

The draft was disclosed on Sunday. EU countries are due to discuss it on Wednesday, 18 November, and the Irish presidency is seeking agreement among governments at a meeting of environment ministers in December. The European Parliament must also establish its position before negotiations on a final law can be completed.

Changing the benchmark

A central feature is a change to the benchmarks used to calculate how many allowances industrial installations receive free of charge. The benchmarks are intended to reflect the performance of the most efficient producers, creating a yardstick against which other installations are measured.

For a product benchmark, the current method uses the average greenhouse-gas emissions of the best-performing 10 per cent of installations making that product. The presidency’s draft would instead base benchmarks on the most efficient installations accounting for 10 per cent of a sector’s production volume.

The distinction is between selecting a share of installations and selecting installations by their share of output. It can change which plants are included in the calculation and therefore the benchmark used to work out free allocations.

The draft would also introduce benchmark reductions through annual updates, rather than applying a change in one step every five years. That would spread out reductions in the calculation of free allowances. It would not remove the underlying requirement for covered operators to account for their emissions.

Why free allowances matter

Under the trading system, an allowance covers one tonne of carbon dioxide or its equivalent in other greenhouse gases. Covered operators must monitor their emissions and surrender enough allowances to account for them each year. Allowances can be auctioned or traded, while eligible installations receive some free.

Free allocation is intended to reduce the risk of carbon leakage: production moving outside the EU to places where businesses face weaker climate rules. It can lower the number of allowances an installation needs to buy, but it does not remove the obligation to cover its emissions.

Where a plant does not receive enough free allowances to cover its emissions, it can reduce those emissions, buy additional allowances or combine the two. The amount received depends on the applicable rules, including benchmarks and production levels, so the position of one installation cannot be assumed to represent every manufacturer.

Investment plans and smaller sites

The EU executive’s wider proposal would, from 2031, generally link full free allocation to verified plans for investment in decarbonisation. Under its main approach, 80 per cent of the allocation would be released while the remaining 20 per cent would be held back until investment and emissions-reduction conditions were met.

The Irish draft would exempt installations that received fewer than 5,000 free allowances over the previous allocation period from the proposed investment-plan requirement. That is an exemption from a proposed condition for free allocation, not a blanket exemption from the carbon market.

For larger installations, the compromise would allow access to the final 20 per cent once construction begins on an eligible decarbonisation project, rather than waiting for the project to be completed. The timing of an allowance release is different from the timing of any emissions reductions, which would depend on the project itself.

The draft would also broaden opportunities to pool investment across industrial clusters and supply chains. It would clarify that certain heat-pump investments connected to district-heating networks could count towards the investment requirements. The final wording and practical conditions remain open to negotiation.

A separate short-term measure

The wider review should not be confused with a separate provisional agreement reached on 12 November. That measure concerns free allowances for certain energy-intensive industries whose allocations are calculated using heat and fuel benchmarks, covering the period from 2026 to 2030.

The Council and Parliament agreed a cushion of roughly 121 million free allowances under that targeted measure. It still requires endorsement and formal adoption. The Irish presidency’s new compromise follows a different path: it seeks to shape the governments’ position on the broader revision before talks with Parliament.

Pin It on Pinterest