New rules will require subscription businesses to email customers before they are charged again, and to spell out how to leave. The government has pencilled in a figure for how many will take the hint. Having run that email as a live test, I think it is too high.
Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act, subscription traders will have to send reminder notices before renewal payments: broadly once every six months on a monthly plan, before each renewal on longer cycles, and ahead of the first charge when a free or discounted trial converts. Section 258 sets the trigger. What has to go in the notice is set out in Schedule 23, and it is not subtle. The notice must tell the customer how to end the contract, where to do it and by when, and that information has to be more prominent than anything else in the message.
The regime is not live yet. The government published its response to the implementation consultation in April and now anticipates commencement in spring 2027, though no commencement regulations have been laid.
Where the eight per cent came from
Whitehall has already modelled the effect. The impact assessment behind the measures assumes that eight per cent of people who receive a reminder will go on to cancel an unwanted subscription, worth £47m a year to consumers.
The provenance of that number is worth knowing. It does not come from subscriptions. It is adapted from Ofgem’s collective switching trials in the energy market, where three rounds of communication lifted switching from three per cent to 27 per cent, then cut to a third on the reasoning that one reminder does less work than three.
That is a defensible way to produce a planning figure. It is not evidence about what happens when a retail brand emails its own subscribers.
What happened when we sent it
We have been running that email as a controlled test in one YOCTO subscription brand, going out seven and five days before renewal to half the eligible base, the other half held back.
Cancellations among the group that received it rose by roughly four to five per cent against the group that did not. Lower than the government’s assumption, though the two are not measuring quite the same quantity. Over the same fortnight, it produced several thousand pounds of upgrade value from that half of the list.
That last point is the one worth carrying. Our email was not a bare reminder. It also asked people to move up to a longer plan, so some of those cancellations belong to the ask, not the reminder. Brands will not choose whether this email goes out. They will only choose what is in it.
An email that lands at the exact moment a customer is deciding whether to stay is a strange thing to hand to the compliance team.
George Kapernaros is the founder of YOCTO, a retention agency for subscription and DTC brands.