First Secretary of State Louise Haigh says a proposed change to the age of consent deserves careful consideration after campaigner Mia Latter called for stronger protections for 16- and 17-year-olds.
Latter has waived her anonymity and publicly alleged that Russell Brand raped her when she was 16. She has called for a staggered approach to consent law that would restrict sexual relationships between adults and teenagers aged 16 and 17. Brand previously denied the allegation made against him by Latter.
Haigh said changing the age of consent would be a major step, but that the proposal deserved scrutiny. She said lawmakers needed to listen to the experiences of people such as Latter when considering the issue.
Her remarks are not an announcement that the law has changed. Nor did the remarks set out a bill, the details of a formal review or a timetable for legislation. The immediate development is a senior minister’s response to a campaign for a change, rather than a settled government policy.
What a staggered approach would mean
Latter’s argument concerns the difference between relationships among teenagers of a similar age and sexual relationships involving a much older person. A staggered approach would take account of the age of the other person as well as the age of the teenager.
The case for such a change is that a large difference in age can come with an imbalance in experience, influence or power. Supporters of additional safeguards want the law to give clearer protection to young people in those circumstances, even where they are above the general age of consent.
The published proposal does not provide a complete set of legal provisions. Questions such as the precise age of an older partner, how an age gap would be defined and what exceptions might apply would need to be resolved before the effect on particular relationships could be assessed.
The issue has been raised before. Latter, then known publicly by a pseudonym, called for a debate about staggered ages of consent in 2023. Her decision to identify herself and Haigh’s response bring a new stage to that discussion; the idea itself is not new.
What the law currently says
In England and Wales, the general age of consent to sexual activity is 16. A person under 16 cannot legally consent to sexual activity. At 16 and 17, a young person can legally consent, but that does not mean every sexual act involving them is lawful.
Consent requires a person to agree by choice and to have the freedom and capacity to make that choice. Non-consensual sexual activity is unlawful regardless of a person’s age. Reaching 16 does not remove protection against rape or sexual assault.
There are also offences covering sexual activity with under-18s in certain positions of trust. Depending on the circumstances, these can apply where an adult has a qualifying role in a young person’s education, care, sport or religious instruction. The law defines the relationships and conduct covered; it does not make every contact between an adult and a 16- or 17-year-old a position of trust.
Those existing rules address specific relationships and situations. The campaign for a staggered age of consent asks whether a wider age-based restriction should apply beyond them. The answer would depend on the design of any proposal, including how it treated relationships between people close in age.
The allegation and the separate court case
Latter’s allegation was not part of the trial that led to Brand’s recent convictions. Police have said their investigation into her allegation remains ongoing. They said prosecutors advised that further information was needed before a charging decision could be made.
Brand was sentenced separately at Southwark Crown Court on 9 November to ten years and six months in prison following convictions for one count of rape and three sexual assaults against four women. He was acquitted of two other rape charges and an attempted indecent assault. Those verdicts do not determine Latter’s separate allegation, which Brand has previously denied.
The distinction matters to the debate. Latter’s allegation concerns conduct she says was non-consensual. Her campaign also asks lawmakers to consider a broader question: whether the current age-related rules give enough protection to teenagers when the other person is an adult.
Any legislative change would have to be defined and considered through the relevant parliamentary process before it could take effect. For now, the existing law remains in place, while Haigh’s comments leave open what, if any, action ministers will choose to take.