6°C

overcast clouds

TFL Updates
London Daily News

Burnham defends closer EU ties while keeping Brexit red lines

Burnham defends closer EU ties while keeping Brexit red lines

Prime Minister Andy Burnham has said Britain has lost more than it has gained over the decade since the Brexit referendum, as he pressed for closer cooperation with the European Union ahead of a summit in Brussels.

Speaking at the Welsh Labour conference in Llandudno on Saturday, 14 November, Burnham said he wanted a food and farming agreement that would ease the burden on Welsh exporters and help bring down food prices. He also said he would respect Labour’s manifesto red lines and the result of the referendum.

His comments were a fresh intervention before the 20 November meeting, rather than an announcement that a deal had been signed or that the government had changed its position on EU membership. Burnham had already criticised the effects of Brexit and argued for closer ties in the run-up to the conference.

He told delegates he believed the Conservatives had given Britain a harder Brexit than people had expected when they voted in 2016. That was his political judgement about the outcome and voters’ expectations, not a finding that every voter wanted the same relationship with Europe.

What Burnham wants from the summit

The prime minister said a food and farming deal could remove some of the paperwork facing exporters and help Welsh farmers and businesses selling products such as lamb and shellfish. He linked the proposed agreement to the cost of living, saying he wanted lower food prices as well as reduced costs for businesses.

Those are aims for an agreement still to be concluded and implemented. Even if checks and administrative costs are reduced, the effect on individual businesses and household prices would depend on the final rules and how savings are passed through supply chains.

The UK and the EU have been working towards an agreement covering food safety and animal and plant health, often described as sanitary and phytosanitary rules. Since the end of the Brexit transition period, many products sent from Great Britain to the EU have required health certification and border checks.

For animal products, an export health certificate can cost around £200 per consignment. A mixed load may need several certificates, adding to costs before any physical delays are considered. The requirements vary by product, so they should not be treated as a single charge on every food shipment.

The proposed arrangement is intended to remove most certificates and routine controls on covered agricultural and food movements between Great Britain and the EU. It would also involve the UK keeping relevant rules aligned with changes in EU law. The government estimates the agreement could add up to £5.1 billion a year to the UK economy by 2040; that is a projection, not a benefit already realised.

Closer alignment is also a point of contention. Supporters argue that common rules can make trade easier, while critics question how much control Parliament would have over future changes. The practical balance between easier trade and regulatory autonomy will depend on the agreement’s final terms and the arrangements for scrutiny.

The manifesto limits

Labour’s 2024 manifesto said Britain would remain outside the EU and ruled out a return to the single market, the customs union and freedom of movement. Burnham’s conference remarks reaffirmed those limits while making the case for cooperation within them.

The distinctions matter. A sector-specific food agreement is not the same as joining the EU’s single market, which covers a much wider range of economic activity. A customs union concerns a common approach to tariffs on goods from outside it; membership of one would not automatically remove every regulatory check on goods.

Alongside food rules, the two sides have been working on linking their emissions trading systems and creating a youth experience scheme. Such a scheme would depend on its agreed terms and would not in itself amount to the unrestricted freedom of movement ruled out in Labour’s manifesto. None of those proposals should be confused with a completed return to EU membership.

Burnham has also said he wants to examine longer-term options for the UK’s relationship with the EU, while ruling out major changes before the next general election. Conservatives have criticised moves to align more closely with EU rules, while the Liberal Democrats have argued for rejoining the single market and establishing a customs union.

A Welsh political setting

The speech came as Welsh Labour considered how to recover after losing its position leading the Welsh Government in the Senedd election. Burnham told delegates the party needed to listen and work together, and said he wanted a devolution model that worked through the Senedd and gave more power to Welsh communities.

He is due to meet European Council president António Costa and European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen at the Brussels summit. Leaders are expected to review cooperation since the first UK–EU summit in 2025. What they agree on 20 November, and what must happen afterwards to put any deal into effect, remains to be seen.

Pin It on Pinterest