More London companies are appointing independent directors earlier in their growth. Adrian Lawrence FCA explains what a first non-executive should bring, and why choosing from a familiar circle is the most common mistake.
By Adrian Lawrence FCA
London produces more growing companies than anywhere else in the UK. Tech scale-ups in Shoreditch, private equity-backed businesses in the West End, family firms that have quietly reached £20 million or £50 million in turnover. Sooner or later, almost all of them reach the same point: the founder or owner realises the business has outgrown a board made up only of the people who run it.
That is when the conversation about a first non-executive director begins. In my experience, the decision to appoint one is usually right. How the person is chosen is where things go wrong.
Why the first appointment is coming earlier
A few years ago, many private companies only appointed an independent director when an investor insisted on it. That is changing, and London businesses are often ahead of the curve.
Part of the reason is scrutiny. Directors’ responsibilities have not become lighter. Since 18 November 2025, every new director has had to verify their identity with Companies House before being appointed, and existing directors are being brought into the same regime over a twelve-month transition. The failure to prevent fraud offence, in force since 1 September 2025, has made larger organisations think harder about who on their board is actually challenging the controls. Listed companies, meanwhile, are working through the 2024 UK Corporate Governance Code, including the new requirement for boards to declare that their material internal controls are effective.
Most private companies are not bound by the Code. But the expectations it sets filter down: to lenders, to acquirers, to private equity investors and to the larger customers who now ask suppliers about their governance. A business preparing for investment or a sale is judged partly on its board.
The other reason is simpler. Founders are recognising that they need someone who will tell them what they do not want to hear.
The problem with choosing from a familiar circle
London’s depth of talent cuts both ways. There is no shortage of experienced people willing to take a board seat. The danger is that a founder appoints the first credible person they already know: a former colleague, an adviser, a friend from an industry dinner, someone introduced by their accountant.
Those appointments feel safe. They are often the weakest. A non-executive who owes their seat to a personal relationship rarely becomes the independent challenge the board needs. They may be excellent people, but the conversation in the boardroom tends to stay comfortable.
A first non-executive director should be chosen for what the business is missing, not for who is easiest to approach. That usually means looking well beyond the founder’s own network.
What a first non-executive should bring
Every board is different, but the strongest first appointments I see tend to share three qualities.
Relevant experience of the next stage, not the last one. A business preparing to raise capital needs someone who has been through a funding round. A business planning to sell needs someone who has sat on the board through an exit. A company expanding internationally needs someone who has done it. The question is not “who is impressive?” but “who has already solved the problem we are about to face?”
The confidence to challenge. A good non-executive asks the uncomfortable question in the meeting, not afterwards in the car park. That requires both independence and the personal authority to be heard by a founder who is used to making every decision.
Financial literacy. Even when the first non-executive is not a finance specialist, they need to read management accounts critically, understand cash and covenants, and know when the numbers are telling a different story from the narrative. Many first appointments go on to chair the audit or risk discussion when the board grows.
Setting the role up properly
The appointment itself is only half the work. London businesses that get the most from a first non-executive tend to do a few things well.
They write a clear brief. What is the board trying to achieve over the next two to three years, and where are the gaps? A specific brief attracts specific candidates.
They agree on the time commitment. Most private company non-executive roles involve between one and three days a month, more around board meetings, fundraising or a transaction. Being clear about this avoids disappointment on both sides.
They put the board on a proper footing. Regular meetings, papers circulated in advance, minutes that record decisions and actions. A non-executive cannot add much to a board that only meets when there is a crisis.
They pay properly. Fees for a first non-executive at a growing private company in London vary widely, but businesses that offer a token amount tend to attract token commitment.
Using London’s depth to your advantage
The good news for London’s growing businesses is that the talent is here. The capital has the UK’s deepest pool of experienced directors across financial services, technology, private equity, professional services and consumer businesses, many of whom are actively looking for portfolio roles.
The challenge is finding the right one rather than the nearest one. For businesses that want a structured search rather than a list of familiar names, specialist non-executive director recruitment in London can widen the field and test candidates against the board’s actual needs.
A first non-executive director is one of the most important hires a growing business will make. It deserves the same rigour as any senior executive appointment, and usually rewards it.
About the author
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of FD Capital Group, a group of five specialist recruitment firms that includes NED Capital, which recruits non-executive directors, chairs and committee chairs for UK boards. A Fellow of the ICAEW and a former listed-company Finance Director, he has more than 25 years’ experience at C-suite level.