9°C

heavy intensity rain

TFL Updates
London Daily News

Study links 2023 heat-pump grant rise to higher installation rate

Study links 2023 heat-pump grant rise to higher installation rate

An increase in the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant in 2023 was associated with a 24 per cent rise in monthly heat-pump installations in northern England relative to Scotland, a newly published study has estimated.

The analysis used 260,000 certified installation records and examined the 20 months after the policy change. It estimates that the difference amounted to roughly 7,200 additional installations in northern England over that period. The finding is an estimate from a comparison of trends, not a count of every heat pump fitted across the United Kingdom or proof that each installation was caused by the grant alone.

A policy change with a built-in comparison

On 23 October 2023, the voucher for an air-source heat pump under the scheme increased from £5,000 to £7,500. The voucher for a ground-source heat pump rose from £6,000 to £7,500. Accredited installers apply for the vouchers on behalf of households and deduct the grant from the installation invoice.

The scheme applied in England and Wales. Scotland had separate clean-heating arrangements and did not change its grant level at that point. That difference allowed the researchers to compare how installation patterns changed in northern England and Scotland before and after October 2023.

The paper’s wording matters. Its statistical comparison is between northern England and Scotland, not a direct estimate for every English region or for the whole of Great Britain. It also does not suggest that Scotland had no heat-pump market. The study uses the different policy settings to estimate the additional change associated with the higher English grant.

What the installation estimate means

The 24 per cent figure describes the estimated monthly difference in installations after the grant increase, relative to the Scottish comparison area. It should not be read as a 24 per cent increase in every month, in every local authority, or in every type of property. Nor does it establish a household-by-household reason for choosing a heat pump.

The researchers used a difference-in-differences approach. This compares the change over time in the area affected by the new grant with the change over time in an area whose grant did not change. It is designed to distinguish a policy effect from trends already affecting both places, but it remains an estimate based on the records and comparison selected for the study.

The research also examined reported installation costs before grants were deducted. It found an average fall of about £830. Combined with the £2,500 rise in the air-source heat-pump voucher, that led the authors to estimate that average out-of-pocket payments fell by more than the extra grant alone. This is a study-level result, not a promise about the price, grant or saving available to an individual household.

Installer competition is part of the picture

The paper links the stronger take-up to changes in local supply as well as to the larger voucher. Areas with more installer competition before the reform showed a larger expansion in installations and a larger fall in reported costs. The analysis points to new installer entry, a wider geographical reach by existing installers and a shift towards smaller, higher-efficiency heat pumps as possible parts of that adjustment.

Those findings do not mean that every installer cut prices or that every property is suitable for the same equipment. Installation costs can depend on the building, the existing heating system, the design of the replacement system and the work needed to fit it. A grant changes the upfront calculation, but it does not settle those practical questions.

A London research result with UK policy relevance

The work was produced by researchers at the London School of Economics and Political Science, Imperial College London and UCL. Its subject is a national policy question, while its evidence is drawn from northern England and Scotland. The study does not publish a separate estimate for London, so it would be wrong to present the 24 per cent figure as a result for the capital.

For policymakers, the study adds evidence that the size of an upfront grant can affect the pace of installation and the way local supplier markets respond. It does not measure whether every household’s energy bills fell, whether a particular installation performed as expected, or the emissions achieved by each system after fitting.

The result is therefore most useful as evidence about one policy change over a defined period. The next questions are whether the same pattern holds in other areas, how demand and supply develop over longer periods, and how grant design interacts with installation quality, household circumstances and the wider cost of low-carbon heating.

Pin It on Pinterest