Being an adult is hard. You grow up, and you reach an age where people expect a certain degree of maturity from you. Your parents want you to leave the proverbial nest and make your own. And to top it off, society at large wants you to do that one dreaded thing everyone has to contend with: find a job.
Back in the 90s and even before then, you’d have to go through the act of picking up a newspaper and looking at who was hiring. Or you’d explore your local area for a place that was in need of work. In today’s digital age, though, you’d think it’d be much easier. And you wouldn’t be completely wrong. These days we have this thing known as “job boards” to help us find jobs. So before we get into dissecting their flaws, let’s try to understand what they are and how they work.
What’s a job board?
A job board is simply an online space where employers post job listings and employees post their applications. Job boards see widespread use every day from both employers and employees. However, for employees, it’s not as rosy as it may seem.
The job board industry functions much like a paid-for advertising scheme. The goal of the job board is to act as the place where employers can get as many candidates as they can to try and apply for their company. They also exist as a means for job advertisers to turn their websites into paid-for-click advertisements, as the number of clicks and traffic each website gets turns into something meaningful, boosting overall SEO along with the job posting. It’s a very clever marketing strategy at the end of the day.
But this doesn’t mean the system is not without its faults. Job boards are routinely seen as a source of criticism on all sides of the spectrum. But the main volume of criticism comes from the job seekers’ perspective.
The job seekers’ perspective
There are a million different issues candidates face when it comes to using a job board. Below, you’ll find a few key pointers as to what those hurdles are and why they pose such a hurdle when it comes to finding jobs.
Difficulty standing out
Chris McDermott, Founder of Intercoastal Consulting & Life Care Planning said, the first major hurdle that comes with job boards is that job seekers find it hard to stand out. Boards are filled with millions of different candidates trying to find a job at the same time. For a single candidate trying to present themselves as unique or better, it becomes a huge struggle. And because of that, candidates stop trying to apply to a single worthwhile job and just try to apply to every job they come across. Which is reasonable, yet it creates problems for employers and candidates alike.
Ghost job listing
James Owen, co-founder of Click Intelligence believes, another issue caused by job boards is ghost listings. Ghost job listings are seemingly vacant posts looking for candidates to apply. However, the reality is that these posts aren’t hiring anybody. They simply exist to fool candidates into thinking they are. At the same time, they’re on the rise and can’t be reported as scams. This is an issue for candidates because not only does it bring down morale, it also keeps them waiting on posts that may turn over but never actually do.
Applicant tracking system
ATS systems are another hurdle when it comes to finding jobs. That’s because ATS relies on filtering candidates through keywords. If candidates don’t meet the criteria in keyword usage, then they massively decrease their chances of getting the jobs they would excel at. It’s a very un-inclusive and inefficient process.
The employer’s dilemma
The employer’s dilemma is the fact that they want the candidate of best fit to join their company. So the employer ensures that out of the thousands to millions of candidates applying for their applications, the numbers are shaved off. However, using automated systems and paying for large-scale advertising doesn’t automatically equate to high-quality candidates.
You fall into the trap of quantity over quality. This, in turn, causes the issue of paying for a job listing that ultimately falls through and doesn’t amount to anything. To top it off, there’s no proper way to screen candidates efficiently before the job interview process. Interviews, at their core, are lengthy in time and money. It can often take days to weeks to find the right candidate for a job. And sometimes, when you’re looking for a single candidate, you may not even find them.
What makes the process worse is that all those potential candidates who were applying in droves have all been sifted out. So now you need to hope that the new batch of candidates you’re getting has a diamond in the rough. If not, the process rinses and repeats itself.
At the end of the day, it’s reasonable to suggest that job boards are like drawing a lottery. More often than not, you’ll be met with pennies, but if you get insanely lucky, you may take it all. However, our suggestion would be to increase your networking because, at the end of the day, that’s how one gets jobs.