Ukraine’s president says United States negotiators have asked whether his country would withdraw its forces from the Donbas region in exchange for membership of NATO, but that there is no concrete proposal to consider.
Volodymyr Zelensky described the question as a first in the discussions and said Ukraine was not giving up its land. He said that if a sufficiently detailed security package were confirmed by the US and other partners, he would consult Ukrainian society on whether to accept it.
The remarks were made to journalists on Friday and released on Saturday, following a week of diplomacy involving Ukraine, Russia, the US and European partners. They are Zelensky’s account of what was raised, not confirmation that an offer has been made or that a deal has been agreed. Washington and NATO had not directly confirmed his account when it was reported.
The question over territory
Donbas is the name commonly used for the eastern Ukrainian regions of Donetsk and Luhansk. Russia controls much of the area, while Ukrainian forces remain in parts of it. Moscow has demanded that Ukraine withdraw from territory it still holds there and has opposed Ukrainian membership of NATO.
Zelensky said the American question concerned whether Ukraine would leave Donbas if it joined the alliance. His description of a possible public consultation was conditional on a package being confirmed; it was not an announcement that Ukraine had agreed to withdraw.
He also said any arrangement would be without Ukrainian recognition of occupied territory as Russian. A withdrawal of forces and a change in the legal status of territory are separate questions. His remarks did not set out an agreed plan for either.
The president described a package under discussion with partners that could include security guarantees, a strong Ukrainian army with weapons and financing, and a reconstruction plan backed by identified funding. He stressed that specifics were still needed. The package he described is a subject for discussion, not a set of commitments already in force.
Membership and security guarantees
Membership of NATO would involve a decision by the alliance as a whole, not just by the United States. Existing members decide by consensus whether to invite a country to join, and accession protocols must then be ratified according to their national procedures.
The alliance’s collective-defence provision says an armed attack against one or more members within its scope is considered an attack against them all. Each ally undertakes to assist by taking the action it considers necessary, which can include armed force. It does not prescribe an identical military response by every member.
A separate security guarantee modelled on that provision would not automatically be the same thing as NATO membership. Zelensky said US representatives had also discussed bilateral guarantees resembling the alliance’s consultation and collective-defence provisions. He said the American side had told him US soldiers would not be stationed on Ukrainian soil under the arrangement he asked about. The terms of any such guarantee remain to be settled.
Talks continue after Abu Dhabi and Dublin
The disclosure follows talks involving Ukrainian, Russian and US representatives in Abu Dhabi on 10 and 11 November. Before the trilateral discussions, European, Ukrainian and American representatives met with NATO participation to discuss security and coordination. They supported robust guarantees for Ukraine as part of a settlement, without announcing an agreed peace deal.
Zelensky subsequently met US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner in Dublin. He said their discussions included preparations for further meetings and greater European participation. EU leaders later set out a proposed European team involving the EU institutions and France, Germany, Italy, Poland and the United Kingdom.
Europe’s representation is a separate issue from the question of what Ukraine might be offered on territory and security. The talks have not resolved the opposing positions on those matters. Zelensky’s account adds a new description of an American question to the public discussion, while leaving unanswered whether the US and other NATO members would agree on a specific package or how Ukraine would respond to one.